Saw Filing--A Beginner's Primer
Selecting a Saw Vise What do I need to sharpen my saw? Fortunately, the tools that are required to sharpen a saw are easy to acquire and are not very expensive to get your saw cutting right. The first thing you will need is vise. The saw filing vice has only one job: To hold the saw blade securely and at a comfortable height for filing. The act of filing a thin piece of hardened steel causes a lot of vibration. The saw vice dampens vibration and allows the file to cut. If the saw blade vibrates, it makes it impossible for the file to “bite” into the metal that it is trying to sharpen. This causes the file to skitter across the surface of the teeth, resulting in a dull file and dull teeth. There are many different patents of saw filing vises that were made in the past when saw filing was common. In general, you should look for a vise that has no broken parts with accurately closing jaws. Saw filing vises are very nice that have all their finish and are like new. However, finding vises like this is very difficult. Saw filing vises saw hard use, and were often stored where they got rusty and abused. Do not be concerned if your vise is rusty. As long as all the parts are present and the jaws close firmly and lock in place, you have a vise that will do the job. If you like, you can always clean your vise up and repaint it. Most saw filing vises are not rare or collector’s items. Some of the companies that specialized in saw filing vises were Disston, Wentworth and Stover. Any vise that meets the above criteria can be used. For those who can’t find a good vise, there is sometimes a selection on this website. In addition, making a saw filing vise out of wood is a relatively easy task. There are many plans which spell out how to make a properly functioning vise.
Some Thoughts on Making a Saw Vise There are some common attributes that you should consider if you decide to make a saw filing vise. In general, most of these vise plans work in a shoulder vise and are nothing more than two pieces of wood that are hinged at the bottom. Both pieces have stock removed inside the jaws to accommodate the thickness of the blade. They also have the top of each half of the jaw beveled to 45 degrees, so that when the vise is closed it is easier to file the teeth. You should make the vise as long as you can. Ideally, the vise should be as long as the saw that you intend to file. The one advantage that a craftsman made wooden vise has over an iron one is that the entire side of the saw can be sharpened without moving it. In addition, the inside of the jaws should be slightly hollow in the middle. By doing so, you will ensure that when tightened, the entire length of the blade is firmly gripped.
What Size File to Use The next thing that you need is the proper file for the job. You should seek to buy the highest quality file that you can find. Avoid “bargain” files that are made in India or China. The teeth are not hard or durable enough to sharpen a quality hand saw. While they may seem attractive due to price, they will only waste your time and money. I use Nicholson brand files which are available in the maintenance section of this web site. You should seek to use the right size file for the job. In general, saw filing files common is four tapers: Regular, Slim, Extra Slim and Double Extra Slim. There is a lot of mystique and confusion about what size file to use for a certain size saw tooth. The bottom line is that you should use the file which is not too big or too small. You should be able to easily see the teeth when you are filing. In addition, when each edge of the file is used, there should be no significant over or underlap among the three edges. If you use a file that is too small, you will use the same middle section of each face, which will be dull right where you need it to be the sharpest. Near the middle of each face is where the cutting edge of the teeth is sharpened. If you use a file that is too big you will not be able to see the teeth. Also, larger files do not come to as sharp an edge as smaller files. If you compare the edge of a 7″ file with a 4″ file, you will see that the edge of the 7″ file has almost a 1/32″ “flat” on the edge. Compare that to the edge saw of the 4″ file. It comes to almost a knife edge. It is no accident that shorter files as used to file smaller teeth. If all this in confusing, don’t worry. Just use the files that are recommended in the table below and you will be all set.
8″ Regular Taper | |
6″ Regular Taper |
5-5.5 |
7″ Slim Taper | |
6″ Slim Taper | |
6″ XSlim Taper | |
6″ 2XSlim Taper | |
4″ 2XSlim Taper |
File Handles and A Place to File The next thing that you will need is a proper handle for the file that you are using. Do not attempt to file a saw grasping the file by the bare tang. You risk stabbing your palm with the tang if you do so. In addition, it causes the fingers of the hand that are grasping the end of the file to become very fatigued. If you have a lathe, you may enjoy making some handles to fit the various files in your shop. I offer a very convenient high quality handle in the maintenance section of the web site. It has a hardened die which actually threads on to the soft file tang. This causes the file to be securely gripped by the handle, providing maximum safety and comfort. The last thing that you will need is a work area that is properly lit and of the right height. You can’t have enough light when filing saws. However you choose to light your work area, you should be careful not to causes glare on the teeth. By moving various floodlights around the work area, you can find a combination that is right for you. Finally, you should adjust the height of your saw vise so that the angle that is formed by your upper arm and forearm is more of less 90 degrees when you are actually filing a saw. If the vise is too high or low, it will become tiring and causes inefficient work. The time taken to properly set up you filing area will make all the difference in whether you enjoy the process of sharpening your saw, or whether you view it as drudgery.
Different Types of Teeth What are the differences between crosscut and rip teeth? There are two basic types of saw teeth on modern western style handsaws. By western, I mean saws that cut on the push stroke. Crosscut teeth, as the name implies, are used to cut a piece of wood across the grain. Rip teeth are used to cut a piece of wood along the grain. We’ll discuss each in turn.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/92f29/92f291105ca4590ef927c8f80d976f573dcf1bbf" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/584b3/584b3a5a5e62b7164774bdc730d39a2a00f09262" alt=""
All About Fleam The second angle that you will need to know about is called the fleam or bevel angle. If you look closely at a properly files crosscut tooth, you will discover that each tooth is shaped like a lance on the edge. This is due to the fleam angles on each tooth and is what makes crosscut style teeth more challenging to file. To understand why fleam is important, it is necessary to understand how a crosscut tooth actually works to cut wood.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0c523/0c523ddb77e8a6697f2f52c5494379bbd80a6157" alt=""
Practical Fleam Angles
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3791f/3791f966ebbcf178db2ee8c7d1b0977b3c98968b" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d0627/d0627102216abef2f1a47f65e601fcaead7ef421" alt=""
Rip Tooth Geometry Rip Teeth are the easiest type of saw teeth to file, since they do not have any fleam. Rip teeth occur in pitches from 4-7 ppi on hand saws, and from 8-16 ppi on back saws. The most common size of rip tooth for a handsaw is 5 1/2 points per inch. Rip teeth are not as common on back saws that you see available for sale, but in certain applications, such as cutting tenon cheeks or dovetailing, they are invaluable.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/792fe/792feac562bce0d3e483c8b04bdef2217d0bb384" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/30b54/30b54070f08dace5e60c40aea944c9a9ef2c9285" alt=""
How Rip Teeth Cut
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5e05c/5e05c7cfd4dd5d82a3c2be66fa1bead41311859f" alt=""
Making a Rake Alignment Jig So, now that you understand the geometry and workings of the two types of saw teeth, it’s time to put that information to good use. You should have a well lit area that is comfortable to you, with a saw vise and file fitted with a proper handle. The most challenging thing in filing saws is to maintain the same angles on each and every tooth that you file. The hardest part in filing is to keep the face of the file properly inclined to keep the rake angle constant. With even a small change in the way you move your wrist, you can increase or decrease the angle by as much as 10 degrees. In saw filing, this is a huge and unacceptable variation. The task is to ensure that the face of the file that defines the rake angle be kept as constant as possible. Allowing the file to follow the angle that is present on the tooth is a recipe for disaster. With repeated filings, the angle will gradually change to the point where the teeth need to be recut rather than refiled.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0e83e/0e83e0fde6cf443404d2c00346e0871159d71fff" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/33b89/33b89aa517b1c42d14ed2f2a655dff9b063ddf41" alt=""
Jointing
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c5ad5/c5ad55288615989637ce74a5225d179bc72cf2fb" alt=""
Shaping
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d6ac0/d6ac0844f84a9b03d57d2079da39d8a3e06a95a3" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1a3f5/1a3f5537b084c0c83bdc2c643c69d99fc05bcfb7" alt=""
Setting
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/64e4d/64e4dd89f12f616cb079580109b9e169988b6c11" alt=""
Filing This is the most complicated part about sharpening a saw. If you had to extensively reshape your saw’s teeth, you almost certainly have all the confidence and enthusiasm you need to make it a success. Position the saw in the vise as before, with the handle to the right. If you had to extensively reshape your saws teeth, remove the file from the alignment block, and use a fresh edge. If the file has done a lot of cutting, it will be no good for the final filing step. Since the alignment block is determining the rake angle, the only other thing that you have to keep in mind is the fleam angle. If the saw is a rip, the fleam angle is zero and you will file the saw straight across. If it is a crosscut saw, you will need to angle the file to establish the fleam. Again, you will want this to be as consistent as possible. It is not as critical as the rake angle, but you should make every effort to make it as uniform as you can. For all around cross cutting, I like to use a fleam angle of 20 degrees. To remind you of this angle, you can do several things. Some people actually make a jig which consists of a ¾” by ¾” square piece of stock. In the center, saw a slot which is 25 degrees to the right of perpendicular. Saw to a depth of about ¼”. Flip the stick over, and file a slot 20 degrees to the left of perpendicular. Finally, place the jig on the saw blade. If the handle is to the left, the fleam jig should point in the direction of the toe. This is very important. If you don’t want to go to the trouble, some people just lay a ruler on the bench behind the saw defining the proper fleam angle. Use whichever method is easiest for you. Finally, we are ready to start to file the teeth. I have done some considerable research on filing saws and have blended that with my own practical experience. There is one important thing that you have to remember when filing either a rip or a crosscut saw. That is, you want to always file toward the toe of the saw. This may seem like a trivial matter, but it is very important. It is much more important in filing a crosscut saw, but it also makes a difference with rip saws as well. I didn’t used to think so, but have changed my mind after further study and experimentation. Why you ask? The answer is simple. Files cut better on the tooth that is bent away from you than they do on the tooth that is bent toward you. If you start on the handle end of the saw, and work toward the toe, you will be filing the back of one tooth that is bent toward you and the front of the tooth that is bent away from you at the same time. Remember, I said that a file cuts much better on teeth that are bent away from you. By placing the handle to the right and filing toward the toe, you will ensure that the best finish is produced on the front of the tooth, and the poorer finish on the back. Since all western saws work on the push stroke, you want to make sure that the front of the tooth is as keen as it can be. The back matters little- the only important thing is that it meets with the front to form a sharp point. Since a crosscut saw works partly by planing the edge of the cut, the front of the tooth does the majority of the work. On a rip saw, the effect is less important, but by maintaining the same approach, and only filing every other tooth, the front of each tooth will get the same treatment as in a cross cut saw. Confused? Don’t be. Just make sure that you always file toward the toe of the saw. OK, place your fleam jig on the saw so that it points toward the toe if you are using one. Starting at the handle end of the saw, which should be on the right. Make sure you use the side of the rake alignment jig that points to the handle toward the right. Place the file in the first gullet that the tooth to the right is bent away from you and the tooth to the left is bent toward you. This may not be the first gullet on the saw, it could be the second. If you look at the cutting edge from above, you will be able to easily tell which is which. This is why it is important to have at least a little set in the saw, so you can keep track of where you are. So, at this point, the tip of the file is in a gullet. You are starting at the handle end and the tooth on the right side of the file is bent away from you, and the tooth on the left side of the file is bent toward you. If you are filing a crosscut saw, the file will be angled to establish the fleam angle. Align the file to be parallel to the fleam guide that you are using. Also keep the file alignment block parallel to the top of the saw. Sound like just too much to keep track of? The first couple times around, it will be. All I can offer is to think before you file each tooth, and after about a dozen teeth, you won’t have to think about it so much and it will become less stressful.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/cee7f/cee7fc2fa34f885068d1b6115689224571c94b94" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/25935/25935e237593a2b58e52848a80b1f5f8c315b731" alt=""
Finished!
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/25935/25935e237593a2b58e52848a80b1f5f8c315b731" alt=""
Test Cutting The final step is to see how it cuts. Take a square and mark a piece of wood with the proper type of cut for the saw you have just filed. Draw back slightly to start the cut. Since the saw is very sharp, it will be harder to start than it will be after it has been used for a while. Once the cut is started, take long full strokes the entire length of the saw blade. If the saw is properly filed and set, the saw should slice through the cut with a minimum of effort. If the saw rattles as the toe comes out of the cut, the saw has too much set. Continue to stone the edges and equal amount until the rattle disappears. In extreme cases, you may have to lightly peen each tooth to remove some of the set. This is the main reason I like to apply the set after I’m done filing. You ensure that you apply only what you need to make the saw cut properly. The saw should follow the line with a minimum of correction. If the saw drifts from the line, you have one of two problems (maybe both if you are really unlucky). Either the saw has more set on one side than the other, or due to improper filing, the teeth on one side are taller than those on the other. First sight down the edge of the blade. If the teeth are different heights, you will be able to see two ridges, one lower than the other. The only cure for this is to refile the saw. However, more often than not, it is purely due to one side being overset. Stone the side of the saw again that is on the side of the drift. That is, if it is drifting to the left, crossing the line you are following, stone that side of the saw. Also, saws sometimes cut unevenly if some of the burr remains from filing. Make sure that it is all removed by stoning. Once the final tuning of you saw is complete, it will cut flawlessly. I hope that this treatise will serve as an adequate guide to enable you to learn the art of saw filing. It is a skill learned with patience and attention to detail. If you have those two qualities, with proper practice, you will be able to sharpen any saw that you find in the shop.
Sources Used: Bassler, F.M., Why a Saw Cuts, Henry Disston & Sons, Inc, Philadelphia, PA, 1916 Disston Saw, Tool and File Manual, How to Sharpen a Hand Saw, Henry Disston & Sons, Inc, Philadelphia, PA, 1952 Grimshaw, Robert, Saw Filing and Management of Saws, The Norman Henley Publishing Co., 132 Nassau St, NY, NY, 1912 Holly, H.W., The Art of Saw-Filing, John Wiley, 535 Broadway, NY, NY, 1864 Paquin, Jules, Sharpening Saw–Principles, Procedures and Gadgets, Fine Woodworking Magazine, May 1980 Payson, Harold, Keeping the Cutting Edge: Setting and Sharpening Hand and Power Saws, WoodenBoat Publications, Naskeag Road, Brooklin, ME, 1988 Taintor, C.C., Suggestions on The Care of Saws, Taintor Manufacturing Company, 113 Chamber Street, NY, NY, 1908